fbpx

process, process, process!

September 10th 2018

Employment issues again hit the headlines in the last month with cases that had gone before the Employment Relations Authority (ERA).  And again, the learning is the importance of PROCESS when considering terminating an employee.

In Queenstown, a carpenter was awarded $24,500 after being unjustifiably dismissed while in Fiji attending the funeral of a close relative.  He was only told his employment had ended when he contacted his employer to see why he hadn’t been paid.  It was then that he was told they’d run out of work for him.

The company, labour hire firm BF7, didn’t file a reply to his claim and nor did they have a representative at the ERA’s investigation meeting, so, as with a disciplinary process, the ERA were forced to make a decision with the information they had at hand.

It appears absolutely no process was followed, and without the company telling their side of the story to explain otherwise, the sudden and abrupt termination of employment was ruled as unjustified and the company were stung with a hefty fine.

In other HR news, a Waiuku Dairy Farmer was saved from having to make a big pay out to a dismissed employee, despite failing to follow a fair and reasonable process.

Not long after the employment relationship began, Stuart Muir, the employer, started having concerns about Daniel & Loretta Smith, including lateness, their aggressive approach towards animals, and attitude.  He also started getting suspicious about the accuracy of their work history.  Unfortunately, his frustrations led to a hasty termination.

The case was taken to the ERA, who ruled the flaws in the process were numerous:

  1. 90 day trial period was not valid because the employee had started work before signing it
  2. The full list of allegations were not outlined to the employee
  3. The employee was not given time to respond
  4. The proposed outcome was not put to the employee for comment before being finalised

Because of these process issues, the dismissal was found to be unjustified, however the employer narrowly avoided coughing up money because it was found that he had in fact lied about his work history!

The ERA deemed the falsification of the CV led to the Smiths gaining a job they wouldn’t have otherwise got, and for that reason, remedies would not have been appropriate.  Lucky escape for the employer!

Tags: , ,

Category: disciplinary process

Nicki is an absolute rockstar who provides excellent service in so many areas

We love using the team at eight73!!! Nicki is an absolute rockstar who provides excellent service in so many areas and love that we can support another local business in our community.

Adele Phillips, Owner - Pumpn

A very professional approach and she understands our business needs

Nicki has assisted us in various different areas of hr and recruitment, always with successful outcomes. A very professional approach and she understands our business needs.

Charlotte Clapcott, Owner - Hopscotch Childcare Centre

…professional manner, can do attitude & attention to every detail

Thank you very much for your super efficient service. I am truly impressed with everything about eight73 consulting. In particular your professional manner, can do attitude & attention to every detail. You heard everything we needed and attended to it without any delay. I would not hesitate in recommending you.

Gretta Withers, Owner - River Run

It’s clear that the team at eight73 consulting really know their stuff

It’s clear that the team at eight73 consulting really know their stuff, and that takes the stress right out of the processes of job applications and interviews – for both employers and applicants. Thank you Kylie and team!

Molly McGrath, job seeker

…best decision I made in dealing with a recent HR issue

Seeking advice from Nicki was the best decision I made in dealing with a recent HR issue. I felt confident I was complying with best practice and totally supported throughout the process. Can’t recommend eight73 highly enough!

Maria Bradshaw, Manager - Taupo Women's Refuge

… really easy to work with

I have worked closely with Nicki, she is really easy to work with and works with me closely when needed, makes herself available anytime, responds in a timely manner. I am absolutely comforted knowing I can flick of an email anytime with a question or more and she is all knowledgeable and ready. And absolutely affordable!

Frances Ferguson

Nicki provides amazing service!!

Nicki provides amazing service!!

Niki Needham, everypennycounts